I don't think she is a gentle parent either, i am a gentle parent and i take this as... thinking about my children's needs. I try not to shout, i carefully consider what i say and how it makes them feel etc. I did and do still co-sleep when they need me, but they also have their own beds. I will lay on the bed, sing and read until they go to sleep but i will also still have lovely date nights with my husband. I am a part of making sure their relationships with other people especially their dad is an enjoyable one and he is for me (my husband will randomly come in the room and say he is taking mine to the park because he can see i am struggling to work etc). Ultimately as parents we all just want our kids to be happy. Mine are happy when things are relaxed and not stressful. Pea's life seems stressful, from her own doing. Instead of R's dad playing fun games and cuddling up with her and reading a story to bed while pea and E look on and join in with a story, her relationship with her dad is fragmented and stressful.
That isn't gentle parenting. Gentle parenting is teaching your children things in a gentle way. If my kids told my husband he couldn't enter the room i would tell them that that makes him feel sad and we should all sit on the sofa and cuddle and make each other feel nice. She needs to teach her children empathy in order to get on in life and have meaningful relationships. My child is R's age and she absolutely understands the way of the world, its a perfect age to talk about how babies are small and sometimes they need to.... say eat first. She is doing R a disservice in thinking she can't understand this. Just like when we go on a playground and i explain to my child to let the babies go first because they don't understand waiting, but she can as she is 3 and she totally gets it and cheers the babies on when they go down a slide before her.
She shares stories of her playing and showing how amazing she is at phonics etc, but the pure basic skills like loving her dad, going to sleep upstairs and letting her sister have a feed first is going to be the most stressful thing ever. I feel for her i really do. But i think what she will do is grind herself down to dig her heels in for those tandem feeds photos.
We are all just trying to get by and be happy as mums, she doesn't look happy. Her children will look to her to see how she models relationships and how she models self esteem, self nourishment and happiness. She should concentrate more on this than phonics and how amazingly talented she is at counting etc.
Sorry for the essay ha ha
also being a gentle parent means being a gentle parents for all of your kids, not one. This is a hard thing to say but i don't think she is being a gentle parent to E. Would she have left R to cry in another room and sat on the bed when R was a few days old? nope. E doesn't understand why she isn't there, she doesn't know she is feeding R. E just thinks she is away from her. She 100% wouldn't have done that too R.