I do like Rose, and did love some of her dances, but I have to agree. I think Giovanni did a very good job of making her look good in hold, but she's a lot less impressive looking out of it. The first time I watched a clip of her dancing with Nadiya in the Love Story dance I was struck by how much less graceful she looked. Her arm lines were pretty bad (and that was noticeable on the show too.) I wouldn't go so far as to say she only looked good when Gio was dragging her around the floor, because I thought she did quite surprisingly well in some of her Latin dances as well, but she definitely looks a lot better in hold. I wish they'd done their Foxtrot or Viennese Waltz instead of the Argentine Tango on the tour.
And I still don't know what the
duck the judges were looking at with that Argentine Tango. Not a 10 to me. The ganchos looked weird.