Rosemary MacCabe

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
1
Her book isn't great. I think she was going for the Carrie from sex and the city disastrous dating feel. I only read half of it but it every chapter was about a different guy who she had bad sex. She ended the chapters with a cutting remark about them. She was always the victim who was used. A few of the guys were in relationships. She was never in the wrong but was man obsessed. I don't know if it got better as it went on but I couldn't finish it.
 
Her book isn't great. I think she was going for the Carrie from sex and the city disastrous dating feel. I only read half of it but it every chapter was about a different guy who she had bad sex. She ended the chapters with a cutting remark about them. She was always the victim who was used. A few of the guys were in relationships. She was never in the wrong but was man obsessed. I don't know if it got better as it went on but I couldn't finish it.
No it didn't get better
 
Her book isn't great. I think she was going for the Carrie from sex and the city disastrous dating feel. I only read half of it but it every chapter was about a different guy who she had bad sex. She ended the chapters with a cutting remark about them. She was always the victim who was used. A few of the guys were in relationships. She was never in the wrong but was man obsessed. I don't know if it got better as it went on but I couldn't finish it.
It was a very boring pointless read , I too found myself skipping sections and gave up . Went into the recycling bin.
 
Her book isn't great. I think she was going for the Carrie from sex and the city disastrous dating feel. I only read half of it but it every chapter was about a different guy who she had bad sex. She ended the chapters with a cutting remark about them. She was always the victim who was used. A few of the guys were in relationships. She was never in the wrong but was man obsessed. I don't know if it got better as it went on but I couldn't finish it.

I didn't get that from the book at all. She actually was pretty clear that she made bad choices and mistakes. That she had been a witch at times.

I like Rosemary alot and subscribe to her substack but am really disappointed that no new pieces in the last week.
 
I didn't get that from the book at all. She actually was pretty clear that she made bad choices and mistakes. That she had been a witch at times.

I like Rosemary alot and subscribe to her substack but am really disappointed that no new pieces in the last week.
As I said I didn't finish the book. I thought that she couldn't help herself at the end of chapters with a remark about the man in question e.g. his average looks or his current life situation. So while she may have said her own behaviour or choices were poor at times, she had to get the sting in at the end. Just my opinion.
 
I listened to a sample on audible. To paraphrase Rosemary, I mean, I cannot?
---
To quote Rosemary ‘lol’ 🤣
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7833.png
    IMG_7833.png
    101.3 KB · Views: 40
Last edited:
Between this and the new substack, how is the woman still calling herself a writer?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7834.png
    IMG_7834.png
    76.8 KB · Views: 49
Is it just me that looks at this and just sees a bunch of words which make absolutely no sense together?
Word salad
---
I see someone who just parrots what she has read on Twitter
Absolutely! The substack she posted is some of the worst writing I have seen in a while. I have corrected student essays that were streets ahead of that particular string of word art.
 
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
Back
Top