I really don't know why that was, tbh and I am fully prepared to blame the teen magazines who seemed to have chosen her as the "nice" one, the girl-next-door if you want. Liz was also always on the good side but Jenny wad best and it was Natasha first and Jenny last and they seemed to just run with that. s the "bitchy" one if that makes sense? I quite distinctly remember one of those magazines running a poll which Atomic Kitten member people like and it was Natasha first and Jenny last and they seemed to just run with that. Whatever those opinions are based on, no idea.
Looking at Natasha, I'm much more ready to believe you and your friend rather than some discontinued 00's teen rag.