Idina Menzel

[Jay-cloth Cow]

I’ve been a fan since I saw her open Wicked in London, met her a few times over the years, she is talented and lovely.

I love that she was lovely when you met her, it's always great to hear when celebs are nice in person! I wish I'd seen her as Elphaba, Wicked is my favourite musical (seen it 4 times) and the most recent one in the West End (Laura Pick) was the closest to Idina vocally I've seen. The Wicked soundtrack with Idina and Kristen Chenoweth is the soundtrack to my walks!

 

[Mrs McCarthy]

She does have a good voice, but I don’t think she was right for Elsa. She has a voice of an older woman, not a 20 year old girl.
In Frozen 2 they had Aurora to sing for the voice of the spirit. They should have had her as Elsa.