I’m not a Carrie fan or a hater just happen to like going the theatre and have seen a few shows she’s been in.
I actually liked her Eponine back in the day and personally think this is her best role (I haven’t seen her Fantine so this may be better now she’s grown as a performer etc).
I think Carrie suits the older musicals like Les Mis and revivals rather than new musicals.I’ve no idea why but when I’ve seen her in Addams and Heathers while she was by no means bad (she’s an incredible singer there’s no doubting that) she just seemed very out of place and ‘frumpy’ is always the word I use when talking about her performance in Heathers.