Carrie Hope Fletcher #44 red, the colour of Joel’s flags

How did you discover Carrie

  • Through someone else eg Tom/McFly, another Youtuber

    Votes: 382 47.8%

  • Her YouTube channel

    Votes: 229 28.6%

  • Musical Theatre

    Votes: 133 16.6%

  • Her books

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Something else

    Votes: 56 7.0%
  • Total voters
    800
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
1
LaLaLayla said:
Has anyone else actually … softened … towards Joel after that? I feel like he was somewhat friendzoned (just zoned actually) for years and he’s finally got a scrap of attention and he’s over the moon and will just bend over backwards in order to keep her and keep her happy? He seemed really proud of the little proposal treasure hunt thing, and in fairness it’s very cute! I feel like he’s always had a crush on her and now he’s just swept up in it all!

Still think he can be a bit creepy, but I think that’s just everything combined
Click to expand...

I mean I think it's shown all along, and was really highlighted in this live, that he is 50,000x more into her than she is into him. He does look like he can't believe his luck and now he's just really enthusiastically trying to hold on. Which is probably also why he comes across as so creepy in posts.
 
Elinie said:
I wonder if he ever thinks about that. That Carrie ignored him all those times for YEARS and then suddenly when she's been recently broken up with and is miserable about being single she's suddenly ready to talk to him. That has to sting a bit? Does he not care?

Although now that I think about it, I guess she's already spinning this into something positive with her story about how she's been through experiences that made her ready to love Joel the way he deserved.
Click to expand...

I don't think it stings for him because he's so excited at what he nabbed and couldn't care less how he got there

Also, yeah, it is telling that she ignored 8 years of Facebook DMs from him. Feel like Facebook messages are harder to lose track of and less used than Instagram or Twitter DMs. Also, they work in the same industry. If someone I worked with or was in my circle (no matter how loosely) reached out, I probably would send a quick reply out of courtesy, given they aren't a literal stranger. I can totally imagine her for 8 years seeing another message from Joel and rolling her eyes at how creepy and odd he is. Then she hit him up post-breakup because she knew he was always into her

Elinie said:
I mean I think it's shown all along, and was really highlighted in this live, that he is 50,000x more into her than she is into him. He does look like he can't believe his luck and now he's just really enthusiastically trying to hold on. Which is probably also why he comes across as so creepy in posts.
Click to expand...

Creepy in posts is an understatement. Did he not film them making out on the bed in Croatia then put it on TikTok. That's literally filming and posting foreplay. Carrie has been weird in past relationships but never on that level
 
Carrie replying to Joel's message from 2014: Oh wow, sorry it took me so long to reply. I've been so busy with other guys for the last eight years. Anyway, you still up for that drink? OR how about something better? I have a premiere event thing coming up and I don't want to walk the red carpet as a single woman because I'm nearly 30 and it's pathetic to not be married already AMIRIGHT?!
 
She didn't reply to his messages once over the 8 years?? I don't find that creepy from him, I find that extremely rude of her. If they were chatting when they met at events and stuff, it would be natural to assume he could message her as acquaintences. How freaking rude is Carrie to just blatantly ignore a colleague/acquaintence.
 
LaLaLayla said:
Not sure it’s been mentioned (caught up with the last 3 threads in a few days so some stuff was skipped) but anyone notice that his bio says ‘loved’ .. did CHP ruin it or something?
View attachment 1746719 q
Click to expand...
Carries into football now? 🤣 Can’t wait for @ one of the players asking for a freebie like she did with F1

PiefaceG said:
He continued to message her 8 times after not receiving a reply once?

Ew. Stalker.
Click to expand...
She’s essentially dating one of those weirdos you give your insta to, then put them on restricted profile 😭
 
salatblader said:
She didn't reply to his messages once over the 8 years?? I don't find that creepy from him, I find that extremely rude of her. If they were chatting when they met at events and stuff, it would be natural to assume he could message her as acquaintences. How freaking rude is Carrie to just blatantly ignore a colleague/acquaintence.
Click to expand...

I think both are true - it's rude to ignore an acquiantance, but if you do ignore them, it's a bit creepy for them to not take the hint and send 8 ignored messages
 
My observations:
Joel is absolutely smitten with her. His body language is open, he can't take his eyes off her and he really can't stop smiling. I feel that he looks very genuine and is head over heels. Whether it be love, or starstruck or what. He was deferring to her on everything.

Carrie is another story all together. She appeared a bit bored. Her body language was completely different, she had her arms folded across her at one point, she was yawning alot and made very little eye contact with him. Not great reciprocated chemistry.

I know it was kind of intended as a joke, but when he got the lead in Hamilton and suddenly she was interested, having previously ignored his DMs for years...I felt that it was one of those truth jokes.

I felt that they clearly get on very well and have alot in common, and if he's happy to be totally owned, and she likes a puppy, then it will probably work out.
There's no way he's going to have his head turned. Not sure I can say the same about Carrie as she definitely seems less into him.
 
scottishgirl13 said:
Anyone else feel like the engagement story it was just like she’s telling the story of a surprise birthday party or
Something? There’s no giddiness loved up happy newly engaged vibes.
Click to expand...

Yes, so much. There was not one affectionate moment or look or anything. Her smiles seemed so forced. They have alright chemistry as friends but romantically? Nothing. She seemed irritated with him more than anything else.
 
Aw man there was a live? Definitely have to go and watch this. She doesn't sound too chuffed about the whole thing by some of the comments on here

Eta - just watched the disney this or that. Joel's fake belly laugh is awful. It's like those exercises in laughing yoga. And lol at the Cinderella shade. She really doesn't want to be associated with the character does she?
 
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
Back
Top