To be fair to Nadiya, it’s not like she had much to work with
Matt was awful and also very visibly nervous every time he danced, so I don’t think it’s fair to judge her on that. Same with Lee & David who were both awful. Her choreo with Davood was brilliant and I also thought it was really good with Dan, considering the level he was at. She’s never had a partner that she can go all out on choreo with, that’s why I would rather see her with a ringer type than the likes of Dianne, Amy etc.
Dianne’s choreo does nothing for me, she made Tyler who had a lot of potential into a boring contestant who become almost forgettable by the time he left. On paper if any of the female pros are due a really good partner it’s Katya & Nadiya, but there’s a lot of things the producers take into account like height etc that doesn’t always make that possible.