I agree re a 10, it should be for a dance in which everything is perfect. And the 10 paddles need to be taken away from three of the judges
especially in the early stages. They can only have it back under strict conditions
in Shirley's case she would have to promise to drop that 'it's never too early ' ...
It annoys me slightly when the judges give an 8 or 9 but don't say what would have brought the score up. Or they waffle on and on about something vague. I know Joanne Clifton gets criticised mostly for her tyres and pencils
and all that. But I like that she points out stuff that helps me to understand what would improve a particular dancer's scores.
Motsi used to puzzle me, especially when she first started, she would rave about a dance then give a relatively low score. Anton has been all over the place this year, imo. He can give good and critical feedback but then his scores sometimes don't match it.
Just to add regardless of who we like or who we don't, I think they all deserve their places, and I do hope all of their performances go well.