Bridgerton

1 Sort by date Sort by reaction score 2
Suzesnooze said:
She’s getting a lot of negativity in the comments. I agree with them.
Click to expand...
I do think Julia was probably pleased her books were being adapted but now they're in the midst of the adaptation and she can't turn back and I bet she's been convinced to allow Shonda to rewrite lots of it. I don't mind them being colourblind (is that the right term with the casting?) but changing the sex of characters where it will change their story, a story that lots of readers resonate with is just wrong. It's like others in this thread say, it's becoming a bit like Shonda's fanfic version.

I wouldn't be surprised if they end up merging books for a series going forward because there's still a lot of books to go.
 
Last edited:
emmer_moans said:
I do think Julia was probably pleased her books were being adapted but now they're in the midst of the adaptation and she can't turn back and I bet she's been convinced to allow Shonda to rewrite lots of it. I don't mind them being colourblind (is that the right term with the casting?) but changing the sex of characters where it will change their story, a story that lots of readers resonate with is just wrong. It's like others in this thread say, it's becoming a bit like Shonda's fanfic version.

I wouldn't be surprised if they end up merging books for a series going forward because there's still a lot of books to go.
Click to expand...

I’ve not read the books so which characters appearances are different to how they were written in the books please?
 
50sGirl said:
I’ve not read the books so which characters appearances are different to how they were written in the books please?
Click to expand...

In the books there's no racial diversity at all. Everyone is white. So any character that is Black, Asian, Indian, etc is different in appearance.

Which is fine and has made Bridgerton stand out and was explained as to how it worked in this fictional version of Regency England. But the rest of the changes they're doing make little to no sense.
---
emmer_moans said:
I just think it's a bit of a slap in the face to avid readers of the book because they'll be changing Francesca's journey that apparently a lot of people resonated with.

If fans also have to wait 2 years for the next series, I think interest will wane which is why we ended up with overkill on the promo for S3 to get people hyped up again after a 2 year wait since S2.

If they wanted to do a diverse story then maybe Shonda should have written her own story. I wonder if Julia Quinn felt strongarmed into this character change.
Click to expand...

I personally think she was forced to write this or even had it written for her. She has producing credits for the show so she's invested beyond having created the source material. So it must be easier to strongarm her as you say, by saying that this will bring in more money or something.

It might totally be bias confirmation but most of the comments I've seen are negative and the few positive ones are from the media, which Netflix could have paid for, and people wanting to call others bigots for wanting a book adaptation to remain faithful.
 
TheArtisticMouse said:
I haven’t read the books, but I thought Francesca and John were sweet. It showed live doesn’t have to be drama and fireworks all the time, which Bridgerton seems to turn every other relationship into with their lack of communication. It is a shame if they lose that message. It’s not like there isn’t inclusive representation already.
Click to expand...

there’s also lots of stories to tell in the world. From what I’ve read franny has issues with fertility with John. Why can’t that be included? “Just” making her gay seems like a cop out.
 
Chinese_whispers said:
there’s also lots of stories to tell in the world. From what I’ve read franny has issues with fertility with John. Why can’t that be included? “Just” making her gay seems like a cop out.
Click to expand...

And with Michael too. She basically had fertility issues herself. It took her years and thinking it wasn't happening to get pregnant with Michael's baby, I think she was like late 30s? Which in those times was basically a crone.

I don't even want to have kids but as someone who'd have a hell of a time trying and who has friends who've been trying for over a decade, it seems like an unfair situation to lose that representation they had in the book.
 
Considering everyone in the show seem to be able to get pregnant at the drop of the hat, it seems a shame to perhaps erase that storyline for the sake of inclusivity in a show which already does that.
What book is next to be filmed?
I really enjoyed this season but can’t be arsed with the long wait between seasons tbh.
 
Lilykins said:
Considering everyone in the show seem to be able to get pregnant at the drop of the hat, it seems a shame to perhaps erase that storyline for the sake of inclusivity in a show which already does that.
What book is next to be filmed?
I really enjoyed this season but can’t be arsed with the long wait between seasons tbh.
Click to expand...

They haven't said yet but they've heavily hinted that it will be Benedict's turn next, so book 3. I even saw there's been a casting call for what might be Sophie, his love interest. She'd be East Asian if that's the case.
 
QueenBW said:
They haven't said yet but they've heavily hinted that it will be Benedict's turn next, so book 3. I even saw there's been a casting call for what might be Sophie, his love interest. She'd be East Asian if that's the case.
Click to expand...

I do wonder if they’ll introduce the Sophie character in season 4 but his story proper won’t be until season 5. If they even vaguely follow the book there’s a two year time jump and his story wouldn’t really work without that. It would seem too rushed to fit in a time jump in 8 episodes of season 4 (although I guess this would also benefit Francesca’s story with Jon dying). Anyway, they seem to always cram too much into such a short series, I would put it past them to do this and Luke Thompson is starting to show his age, so I don’t think they could really leave it until 2028 before we saw his story!
 
graceanatomy said:
Currently watching Queen Charlotte for the second time and I actually think I prefer it to any of the Bridgerton series, although I do kind of just class it as a Bridgerton series in my mind and forget which details are in QC and not actually in Bridgerton when I'm thinking about the characters etc. 😂
Click to expand...

I’m watching it for the first time I’ve just finished ep 4 and wow it’s better than any of the Bridgerton seasons

I’m obsessed with the character who plays George, I think he’s gorgeous 😅
 
graceanatomy said:
Currently watching Queen Charlotte for the second time and I actually think I prefer it to any of the Bridgerton series, although I do kind of just class it as a Bridgerton series in my mind and forget which details are in QC and not actually in Bridgerton when I'm thinking about the characters etc. 😂
Click to expand...

I enjoyed it more than Bridgerton too!
I want to re-watch it but cry my eyes out at the certain bits in the end 😂
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top