I know what you mean but I think that's probably what I like about Scott's show - it reminds me of my R1 listening days and makes me feel less ancient! I guess the Music Police feature is a bit of a concession though (as most R2 shows have a quiz type feature) and that's my favourite part of his show.Scott doesn't seem to have gelled as well in his new home. I liked him on 1 and can understand why 2 brought him across in the hope his audience would follow, but to me he still sounds like he's doing his Radio 1 show on Radio 2.
Sara Cox is my absolute favourite though and I won't hear a bad word said about her!